An article in Times Online on 2.9.09 suggests that divorcing couples who cannot reach agreement when they separate are being advised to shop around England and Wales to find courts that are most likely to award them a favourable settlement.
The article (correctly) states that there can be starkly differing outcomes, depending upon which part of the country their case is heard in.
We would add: there can be different outcomes from the same judge, depending : upon his or her mood on the morning of your hearing, upon how the previous husband and wife to come before him behaved, and upon his perception that day, of how you or your client presents themselves.
The article says that southern courts tend to be pro-wife, northern courts pro-husband. Our experience is that some judges around here are pro-wife, others pro-husband, and that some are pro-wife one day and pro-husband another day!
Lawyers dealing in international cases sometimes try to get divorces heard in England and Wales because courts here are more flexible than in many other jurisdictions.
So which judges are right? The answer: All of them.
Divorce law in this country is flexible. Judges can, in given circumstances, impose a wide range of outcomes. This is what is meant by “the divorce lottery”. On the same set of facts, you might not get the same result in the same court two days running. The judge would not be “wrong” because he or she can apply their wide discretion to come up with either Result A or Result B.
At Hopkins Solicitors we can remove the divorce lottery for your clients and other contacts. We can get the parties to resolve their dispute by Collaborative Law. With the help of another collaborative lawyer we get the couple around a table. We get them talking. We get them sharing information. We get them to pick their own outcome and avoid a stranger making decisions for them.
When (agreed) papers go to court, they are submitted only for approval. Collaborative Law couples don’t expect a judge to make a decision and therefore don’t run the risk of an unexpected decision. If you know people important to you who may be separating, don’t let them run the risk of the “divorce lottery”. Tell them they can pick their own outcome, recommend Collaborative Law, and send them to us.